Wednesday, May 4, 2011
Wednesday, April 20, 2011
Monday, April 11, 2011
Article Review
ARTICLE REVIEW
TITLE: KNOWLEDGE STRATEGIES OF SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS AND TEACHERS
This study was done by Jamaliah Abdul Hamid from Faculty of Educational Studies, Universiti Putra Malaysia. The general aim of this study is to examine the knowledge strategies of school administrators and teachers in schools to acquire and use information for decision making process in various area of school development. The specific objectives are to identify which knowledge process such as knowledge acquisition, sharing, use and generation has the most number of strategies amongst teachers and administrators in schools. At the same time, the researcher want to examine whether the knowledge process reflect in any order of hierarchical importance and whether there is any significant difference between the area of specialization, work experience and ICT competence and the strategies used of knowledge process.
In this study, the researcher uses a quantitative correlational research design by using survey questionnaire as her main instrument in the process of collecting the data. A questionnaire consist a 23 items that based on the strategies of respondents used in the process of acquiring, sharing and utilized the information. Researcher used a five- point Likert Scale depicting frequency of use that ranging from none at all to the most frequently used on the knowledge process.
The study involved 40 schools in Malaysia. A total of 782 respondents were participated in this study. From this sample, 420 of the respondents came from normal national secondary schools, while 249 from fully residential schools and 113 from technical and vocational schools. The respondents for this study involved 282 of school administrators and 500 of teachers were selected randomly. School administrators include the Principal, Senior Assistants, Heads of Departments and School Counselors.
Research finding shows that the personal knowledge strategies of school administrators and teachers in school are highly correlated to the perception of positive knowledge management environments. Personal knowledge strategies can influence the knowledge culture within schools. It can also influence how much of the school data will always be updated and used by teachers and administrators. Personal knowledge strategies include the knowledge acquisition, knowledge sharing, knowledge storing or using and knowledge generating.
Respondents stated that the knowledge acquisition strategies was the highest in personal knowledge strategies. They stated that they are liked exchanging experiences and information with their colleagues. Teachers and administrators in school who liked to reflect on past experiences can improve on their teaching process. Some of the teachers and school administrators stated that they are liked to read materials such as newspapers and journals, participate in training sessions, seminars and courses in obtaining the information. They also liked to obtain information through watching television, video and films. At the same time, they are surfed the web and use e-mail to acquire or look for information. This method actually was not highly preferred strategies amongst the teachers and school administrators as a means to acquire knowledge. Mostly all the teachers and school administrators agreed that they can get the information through personal communication or hard copies of distributed documents. They said that this method were sufficient information sources for them.
In knowledge storing strategies, teachers and school administrators liked to jot- down ideas during discussion or presentations sessions and keep all the information in the form of hard copy. They are poor effort to digitalize the information because they believe that they need to expert on the high level information maintenance in terms of updating and ease of retrieval. Another reason is the lack of support in schools to encourage the respondents to share their personal knowledge and insights, they heavy workload in the compiling and updating information into the computer. School also needs to appoint dedicated personnel or center to assist teachers and school administrators to input and maintain information in their school databases.
Teachers and school administrators liked to involve in social interaction as their knowledge sharing strategies. They stated that they liked to discuss with their colleagues and friends on the implications of a piece of information on teaching and learning process, formal or informal situations. However, the finding shows that the respondents shared knowledge by being a member of one or various professional groups where one can exchange and share ideas. Another method is by using the internet to disseminate or obtain information and knowledge.
In decision making process, teachers and school administrators mostly use their past experience information and knowledge to help them in problem solving. They believed that their past experience appeared to provide a concrete frame of reference that they can trust and use repeatedly. Teachers and school administrators also consider on experimenting with new ideas during problem solving or decision making process. Sometimes they used their intuition and dare to apply theoretical knowledge as a strategy in solving problem or decision making process.
In term of knowledge generation strategies, teachers and school administrators generated hew knowledge by using analytical strategies. They used this strategy to examine the particular phenomenon. They also combining ideas from the various sources in generate new ideas.
From the findings, we know that there are no significant differences between the area of specialization and teaching experience on knowledge strategies of school administrators and teachers. However, the researcher found that there is significant between level of ICT competence and the knowledge strategies of teachers and school administrators.
As a conclusion, teacher and school administrators need to have a better understanding on the knowledge strategies like knowledge acquisition, sharing, storing or using and generating to consolidate the knowledge culture in their schools. School leaders need to cultivate competent knowledge strategies amongst teachers and staffs in schools. The important thing is the training in using the modern technology such as computer and internet as a knowledge tool to acquire and share information and knowledge. School leaders must to encourage teachers to value their work- based documents as part of intrinsic intellectual wealth of the school in particular, and of the teaching profession in general. Teachers and school administrators must sharing their knowledge and information in decision making and problem solving process. They will get more ideas and work together in that process. They also can sharing their past experience and generate the new ideas for school development. At the same time, teachers and school administrators can be closed and create a good school culture. Means that all the particular in school; teachers, school administrators and staffs have a responsibility to acquiring, sharing, using and generating information and knowledge.
Monday, April 4, 2011
ARTICLES - PHENOMENOLOGY RESEARCH
Phenomenological Research Method
· Posted by Khalid Jamil Rawat on January 14, 2011 at 8:00pm
Phenomenology is different from all other research methods because its field of investigation is different from other methods. What then is this difference? To understand this difference first of all , phenomenology should be differentiated from natural sciences' research methods. The first difference is, natural sciences study the world of nature, the physical nature that follows its own laws commonly known as the laws of nature. Physical nature exists in time and space and it follows the laws of time and space for example causality. On the other hand the subject matter of phenomenology is not the events that take place in the nature, in time and space; rather it studies the purely mental phenomenon. It studies consciousness.
The subject matter of phenomenology is the structure of consciousness, while every thing pertaining to time and space, to physical nature is eliminated from the consciousness. How phenomenology attains to this aim of eliminating every thing bound by time and space, every thing physical from its subject matter? It is done through a change in attitude of the researcher. Phenomenology asks a researcher to suspend all judgments about the physical world. This is called epoche' in the language of phenomenology. Epoche' means' to pocket'. A researcher, while excercising epoche' holds back, or pocket or bracket all the judgments about the physical nature. A researcher has to bracket or hold back even the most basic beliefs about the nature. The most fundamental belief is the belief in the existence. So, while doing a phenomenological investigation, one is not concerned about the existence of an object of consciousness. For example if some one is doing a research on the notion of human soul , one should not be at all concerned about the existence of human soul; rather one has to think about the way the respondents experience human soul in their consciousness. If a researcher is doing a research about the magical practices of a community, he or she should not be concerned about the truth or existence or veracity of such practices. All judgments are to be suspended and the only thing to be considered is how people are experiencing the phenomenon in their consciousness.
Phenomenology is also termed as the study of phenomenon. The word phenomenon actually stands for the phrase' how things appear to one's consciousness. In order to understand the meaning of phenomenon in the context of phenomenology one has to understand that things only give appearance in the consciousness and they are never fully given. So, when you see a horse , you only see a phenomenon of it , neither you see the particular horse you are looking at , fully and completely , in one act of perception , nor you can perceive the universal horse, that you mean when you say the word horse. You only see or are aware of or conscious of a single perspective of a horse, and the inference that what you are looking at is a complete horse is to transgress or transcend your immediate consciousness. So, if after looking at a perspective, a phenomenon of a thing, one infers the whole thing from it, one violates the limits of phenomenology. For, the inference that there is a horse standing in front of you is not immanent in your single perception of a thing. If I see a profile of a picture and infer from this profile the whole image, it means that I have transcended what is given to my consciousness and I have brought my judgment, my learning from my previous experiences to this perception. Where as phenomenology does not allow this inference.
The meaning of the word phenomenon is to further elaborated. For this we have to understand a basic property of consciousness. Consciousness is always intentional. This has a specialized meaning; by saying that consciousness is always intentional, it means that consciousness is always of something and never of nothing. Thus, consciousness is always of something, it is always directed towards something, it always has an object. So while one is conscious of something one is aware of that thing, and that awareness can be attained through various modes of consciousness. You can be aware of a tree through perceiving the tree, through remembering the tree, through imagining the tree, through performing an act on the tree, through making a picture of the tree, through studying about the tree, through talking about the tree. These are different modes of awareness through which you become conscious of an object, the tree. However, in all modes of awareness, the object remains the same, the same tree is the object of your consciousness in all these modes. That common tree is called noema in phenomenology and different modes of getting aware about this tree are called noesis. Thus, the object of consciousness that remains same in its different phenomenon is called the noema and the modes to access this noema are called noesis.
One can access this content of noema and noesis through reflection. So, if I am interested in knowing how people are aware of a 'mobile phone ' I have to consider certain examples of this experience. These experiences will be experiences carried in time and space, therefore, cannot be called purely phenomenological. Because a purely phenomenological experience is purely mental. However, this purely phenomenological is always embedded in the concrete space time events, therefore search for the purely phenomenological starts from these experiences. Once we have studied some examples, we can imaginatively vary the experiences in our minds, to achieve a full range of all the possible experiences of the type under consideration. This step is called imaginative variation. If I look at a computer from four sides, I can think about the infinite possible perspectives from which I can possibly see a computer. But I cannot actually perform these infinite number of perceiving experiences. Thus, I have to rely on my imagination and perform such experiences in my imagination. During these imaginative experiences I try to change certain details and see what is that which remains self same in all the variations. I have to look for invariant attributes, things that are essential to my perceiving of a computer. This is called determination of essences, or eidetic reduction.
Eidetic reduction means to reduce an experience to ideas or essences. So, Initially I look at a house from say five perspectives, and then I repeat the experience of looking at the house from other possible perspectives in my imagination. And in each of these experiences, carried out imaginatively I will try to find out that which remained unchanged, or whose absence from my awareness will not leave that particular house a house. These essential features will constitute the object, the noema in its fullest sense. This noema will be different from the actual objects because it will include in its description all possibilities of that object. Such an understanding of an object is also called horizonal understanding.
By horizonal understanding I mean the total understanding of an object, along with all its possibilities; possibilities that are not given in a single perspective. For example, the fact that a certain physical object, follows the law of inertia, is not given in any of the single perceptions of that object. Rather, such an inference can only be achieved through imaginative variation, in which I imaginatively think about a physical object as a self moving object and consider this property as something accidental to an object or in fact an impossibility.
In practical applications of phenomenology (Husserl's), one first has to identify a phenomenon to be investigated. Then one has to sample different exemplary examples of that phenomenon. These examples are to be studied in depth, and then one has to perform imaginative variation on these examples to find out the invariant element. During imaginative variation one has to consider almost all possible ways of looking at the phenomenon. Eidetic reduction, will then yild the essences.
In social research, one finds a phenomenon to study, say how children of grade 10 experience the learning of a certain mathematics topic. One then has to sample a certain number of exemplary examples. This usually is done through purposive sampling. One selects four or five respondents, or four or five carefully selected groups for group discussion. Then one conduct in-depth interviews or focus group discussions, and try to access the first hand experience of the respondents through using un-structured questions. Interviews usually are very length, and last for an hour or two.
These interviews are recorded and transcribed, and then comes the phenomenological analysis. In this analysis one finds certain themes or underlying currents that are to be focused. The data in each interview seems to cluster around these themes. This is called thematic analysis. Once themes are determined, one has to put together or rearrange the data from all interviews under the found themes, so that no bit of data is left out.
This organized data is then to be subjected to imaginative variation. Each time a noema-noetic stucture is analyzed to find out it invariant elements, and thus essences are found. This reduces the actual to the possible and ideal and a phenomenon is constructed through exposing the full horizon of its possibilities.
ARTICLES - PHENOMENOLOGY RESEARCH
Phenomenologists conduct research in ways that share most of the following positive and negative features.
1. Phenomenologists tend to oppose the acceptance of unobservable matters and grand systems erected in speculative thinking;
2. Phenomenologists tend to oppose naturalism (also called objectivism and positivism), which is the worldview growing from modern natural science and technology that has been spreading from Northern Europe since the Renaissance;
3. Positively speaking, phenomenologists tend to justify cognition (and some also evaluation and action) with reference to what Edmund Husserl calledEvidenz, which is awareness of a matter itself as disclosed in the most clear, distinct, and adequate way for something of its kind;
4. Phenomenologists tend to believe that not only objects in the natural and cultural worlds, but also ideal objects, such as numbers, and even conscious life itself can be made evident and thus known;
5. Phenomenologists tend to hold that inquiry ought to focus upon what might be called "encountering" as it is directed at objects and, correlatively, upon "objects as they are encountered" (this terminology is not widely shared, but the emphasis on a dual problematics and the reflective approach it requires is);
6. Phenomenologists tend to recognize the role of description in universal, a priori, or "eidetic" terms as prior to explanation by means of causes, purposes, or grounds; and
7. Phenomenologists tend to debate whether or not what Husserl calls the transcendental phenomenological epochê and reduction is useful or even possible.
Phenomenology began in the philosophical reflections of Edmund Husserl in Germany during the mid-1890s and is thus over a century old. Before World War I it spread to Japan, Russia, and Spain and also from philosophy to psychiatry;
during the 1920s it spread to Australia, France, Hungary, The Netherlands and Flanders, Poland, and the United States and to research on communicology (then called symbolism), education, music, and religion; andduring the 1930s it spread to Czechoslovakia, Italy, Korea, and Yugoslavia and to research on architecture, literature, and theater. Right after World War II, phenomenology then spread to Portugal, Scandinavia, and South Africa, and also to research on ethnicity, film, gender, and politics; in the 1960s and 1970s it spread to Canada, China, and India and to dance, geography, law, and psychology; and, finally, in the 1980s and 1990s it spread to Great Britain and also to ecology, ethnology, medicine, and nursing.
In view of its continual development and its spread into other disciplines as well as across the planet, phenomenology is arguably the most significant philosophical movement in the 20th century.
Four successively dominant and sometimes overlapping philosophical tendencies and stages can be recognized within the century-old, planetary, and multidisciplinary movement called phenomenology, and an expanding agenda of issues can be related to this broad scheme.
(0) The phenomenological movement began with Husserl's Logische Untersuchungen (1900-1901). This work is most famous for its attack on psychologism, which is the attempt to absorb logic into empirical psychology. Besides logic, this work reflects interest in mathematics, language, perception, and various types of re-presentation (e.g., expectation, imagination, and memory), and also describes how ideal objects might be made evident and known.
Because of its reflective, evidential, and descriptive approach to both encounterings and objects as encountered, the beginning of phenomenology is sometimes characterized as "descriptive phenomenology." If this is the trunk, there is then a succession of four large limbs that branch out from it as the tree of phenomenology has grown (probably smaller branches and even twigs could also be recognized with this image):
(1) Realistic phenomenology emphasizes the search for the universal essences of various sorts of matters, including human actions, motives, and selves. Within this tendency, Adolf Reinach added philosophy of law to the phenomenological agenda; Max Scheler added ethics, value theory, religion, and philosophical anthropology; Edith Stein added philosophy of the human sciences and has been recently recognized for work on gender; and Roman Ingarden added aesthetics, architecture, music, literature, and film.
Alexander Pfänder, Herbert Spiegelberg, and now Karl Schuhmann and Barry Smith have been the leaders of the successive generations of this tendency, which flourished in Germany through the 1920s, but also continues today.
(2) Constitutive phenomenology's founding text is Husserl's Ideen zu einer reinen Phänomenologie und phänomenologischen Philosophie I of 1913. This work extends Husserl's scope to include philosophy of the natural sciences, which has been continued in later generations by Oskar Becker, Aron Gurwitsch, and Elisabeth Ströker, but it is chiefly devoted to reflections on phenomenological method, above all the method of transcendental phenomenological epochê and reduction.
This procedure involves suspending acceptance of the pregiven status of conscious life as something that exists in the world and is performed in order to secure an ultimate intersubjective grounding for the world and the positive sciences of it. Use of this method places constitutive phenomenology in the modern tradition that goes back at least to Kant, and also characterizes the rest of Husserl's work.
Besides those mentioned, Alfred Schutz, J.N. Mohanty, Thomas M. Seebohm, and Robert Sokolowski have both criticized and continued constitutive phenomenology.
(3) Existential phenomenology is often traced back to Martin Heidegger's Sein und Zeit of 1927, the project of which was actually to use an analysis of human being as a means to a fundamental ontology that went beyond the regional ontologies described by Husserl.
Hannah Arendt, influenced by Karl Jaspers (as was Heidegger), seems to have been the first existential phenomenologist after Heidegger. It is also arguable that existentialist phenomenology appeared in Japan with Miki Kyoshi and Kuki Shuzou's early work in the late twenties. However, this third aspect and phase in the tradition of the movement took place chiefly in France. The early Emmanuel Levinas interpreted Husserl and Heidegger together and helped introduce phenomenology into France. This period included Gabriel Marcel and was led in the 1940s and 1950s by Simone de Beauvoir, Maurice Merleau-Ponty, and Jean-Paul Sartre.
This third tendency is concerned with topics such as action, conflict, desire, finitude, oppression, and death. Arendt contributed to political theory and the problematics of ethnicity, Beauvoir raised the issue of gender and old age, Merleau-Ponty creatively continued the appropriation of Gestalt psychology in his descriptions of perception and the lived body, and Sartre focused on freedom and literature.
Existential phenomenology has recently been continued by such figures as John Compton, Michel Henry, Maurice Natanson, and Bernhard Waldenfels.
(4) Hermeneutical phenomenology chiefly stems from the method set forth in Heidegger's Sein und Zeit, according to which human existence is interpretative. The first manifestation of this fourth tendency is Hans-Georg Gadamer's Platons dialektische Ethik (1931), and it reemerged after Germany's National-Socialist period with his Wahrheit und Methode (1960). Other leaders include Paul Ricoeur, Patrick Heelan, Don Ihde, Graeme Nicholson, Joseph J. Kockelmans, Calvin O. Schrag, Gianni Vattimo, and Carlo Sini.
The issues addressed in hermeneutical phenomenology include simply all of those that were added to the agenda in the previous tendencies and stages. What is different is the emphasis on hermeneutics or the method of interpretation. This tendency has also included much scholarship on the history of philosophy and has had extensive influence on the human sciences.
While realistic and constitutive phenomenology arose and first flourished in Germany before and after World War I and existential phenomenology spread out from France after World War II, hermeneutical phenomenology appears to have been most actively pursued in the United States during the 1970s and 1980s.
With the collapse of the Soviet Union and greater contact with the remarkably enduring Eastern European traditions of phenomenology as well as the ever growing interest within Latin America and Asia and indeed in most nations on earth, and, finally, with the continuing increase in international travel and means of communication such as the Internet, it may be that the fourth, hermeneutical, and American period is giving way to a fifth and planetary period of phenomenology.
The shape that phenomenological philosophy will take in the first decades of its second century is difficult to say. Work in the four established tendencies will certainly continue. But perhaps the emphasis will be on philosophical anthropology and related issues such as ecology, gender, ethnicity, religion, and technology as well as continuing concerns with aesthetics, ethics, philosophy of the human and natural kinds of science, and politics.
ARTICLES - PHENOMENOLOGY RESEARCH
PHENOMENOLOGY RESEARCH
Phenomenology is one of many types of qualitative research that examines the lived experiences of humans.(1) Phenomenological researchers hope to gain understanding of the essential "truths" (ie, essences) of the lived experience. Examples of phenomenological research include exploring the lived experiences of women undergoing breast biopsy or the lived experiences of family members waiting for a loved one undergoing major surgery.
The term phenomenology often is used without a clear understanding of its meaning. Phenomenology has been described as a philosophy, methodology, and method.(2) Furthering confusion, the term phenomenology has been used interchangeably with the term hermeneutics (ie, analyses of the written word).(3) This column will provide a brief overview of phenomenological philosophy, methodology, and method.
PHENOMENOLOGICAL PHILOSOPHY
Phenomenologists believe that knowledge and understanding are embedded in our everyday world. In other words, they do not believe knowledge can be quantified or reduced to numbers or statistics.(4) Phenomonologists believe that truth and understanding of life can emerge from people's life experiences. Although phenomenologists share this belief, they have developed more than one approach to gain understanding of human knowledge.
Abstract: This paper compares the research method of phenomenological psychology to other qualitative research methods such as ethnography, participant observation, grounded theory, dramaturgical interviewing and content analysis. An attempt is made to identify similarities and differences. As a prelude, the major meta- theories with which they are associated (phenomenology and symbolic interactionism) and the related differences between natural science and human science are discussed.
Interest in qualitative research methodology appears to have gathered momentum over the last decade (e.g., Rist, 1980). One of the recurrent themes in the discussion of qualitative methods has been the question of whether quantitative and qualitative methods are compatible. Opinion has been divided. Gibbs (1979) made a plea for complementarity of subjectivist and objectivist methods in psychology. Mahrer (1988) has advocated discovery oriented research in the field of psychotherapy, while Sperry (1988) has suggested an integration of positivistic and phenomenological thought to form a more naturalistic approach to the study of brain and consciousness.
The split between those who support and those who do not support complementarity of quantitative and qualitative methodology has also occurred in the field of educational research. For example, Howe (1985, 1988) and Firestone (1987) have argued for compatibility, while Smith (1983) and Smith and Heshusius (1986) have argued for incompatibility.
ARTICLES - PHENOMENOLOGY RESEARCH
Phenomenology as an Educational Research Method-
van Manen
Phenomenology seeks to describe basic lived experience. As a research method it is the study of essences. "The essence of phenomenon is universal which can be described through a study of the structure that governs the instances or particular manifestations of the essence of that phenomenon" (van Manen, 1990, p.10). Research using phenomenology seeks to uncover the meanings in our everyday existence. Its ultimate aim is "the fulfillment of our human nature: to become more fully who we are" (van Manen, 1990, p. 12).
Phenomenology as a type of research is a poetizing activity in that "it tries an incantative, evocative speaking, a primal telling, wherein we aim to involve the voice in an original singing of the world" (van Manen, 1990, p. 13). Phenomenology is both the "description of the lived-through quality of lived experience and the description of meaning of the expressions of lived experience" (p. 25). The description of meaning is a mediated expression and is more interpretive. It is through the use of some type of text or symbolic expression that interpretations are made of life experience. Phenomenological text is descriptive "in that it names something. And in the naming, it points to something and it aims at letting something show itself " (p. 26). The assumption is that the meaning of lived experience is hidden. For van Manen, "a good phenomenological description is collected by lived experience and recollects lived experience?is validated by lived experience and it validates lived experience" (p. 27).
Phenomenology as a research method in education tries to "ward off any tendency toward constructing a predetermined set of fixed procedures, techniques and concepts that would rule-govern the research project" (van Manen, 1990, p. 29). While there is not a set of fixed procedures, van Manen understands hermeneutic phenomenological research in the human sciences as an interplay of six research activities:
(1) turning to a phenomenon which seriously interests us and commits us to the world;
(2) investigating experience as we live it rather than as we conceptualize it;
(3) reflecting on the essential themes which characterize the phenomenon;
(4) describing the phenomenon through the art of writing and rewriting;
(5) manipulating a strong and oriented pedagogical relation to the phenomenon;
(6) balancing the research context by considering parts and whole. (pp. 30-31)
(2) investigating experience as we live it rather than as we conceptualize it;
(3) reflecting on the essential themes which characterize the phenomenon;
(4) describing the phenomenon through the art of writing and rewriting;
(5) manipulating a strong and oriented pedagogical relation to the phenomenon;
(6) balancing the research context by considering parts and whole. (pp. 30-31)
Turning to the Nature of the Experience in Web-based Computer Conferencing
At the heart of every phenomenological research endeavor is a deep questioning of an experience. In my case, I find myself using computers more and feeling a battle between being terrorized as well as enchanted by them. This struggle is the center of the section "Entering the Matrix: Turning Toward." My research is rooted in a life-long journey that has sought to find meaning in the use of technology. As I untangle myself from my own technological matrix, I have begun to discover meaning in the connections I thought were only a matter of circumstance.
This deeply held search for meaning within a technological matrix has taken form in my research question. I want to know what it is like for students using computer conferencing for all or part of their course instruction. Without some sense of how I experience this phenomenon, I enter the research ungrounded. The influences, the ebbs and tides of my own experience, lay hidden. It is from my own experience of computers and WCC that I not only begin to explore my own sense of meaning from the experience, but I begin to wonder what it is like for others. These questions that seek meaning and delve into the nature of the experience beneath will inform me in my own teaching not only in WCC, but in my overall use of computers in my classes. "Phenomenological research is a being-given-over to some quest, a true task, a deep questioning of something that restores an original sense of what it means to be a thinker, a researcher, a theorist" (van Manen, 1990, p. 31).
Investigating the Experience as We Live It
In phenomenology, personal experience is the starting point. The source of personal experience is a description or account of the lived experience. "To conduct a personal description of a lived experience, I try to describe my experience as much as possible in experiential terms focusing on a particular situation or event. I try to give a direct description of my experience as it is, without offering causal explanations or interpretive generalizations of my of my experience" (van Manen, 1990, p. 54). To produce lived-experience descriptions, van Manen suggests:
(1) You need to describe the experience as you live(d) through it avoiding as much as possible causal explanations, generalizations, or abstract interpretations.
(2) Describe the experience from the inside as it were; almost like a state of mind: the feelings, the mood, the emotions, etc.
(3) Focus on a particular example or incident of the object of the experience: describe specific events, an adventure, a happening, a particular experience.
(4) Try to focus on an example of the experience which stands out for its vividness, or as it was the first time.
(5) Attend to how the body feels, how things smell(ed), how they sound(ed), etc.
(6) Avoid trying to beautify your account with fancy phrases or flowery terminology. (1990, pp. 66-67)
(2) Describe the experience from the inside as it were; almost like a state of mind: the feelings, the mood, the emotions, etc.
(3) Focus on a particular example or incident of the object of the experience: describe specific events, an adventure, a happening, a particular experience.
(4) Try to focus on an example of the experience which stands out for its vividness, or as it was the first time.
(5) Attend to how the body feels, how things smell(ed), how they sound(ed), etc.
(6) Avoid trying to beautify your account with fancy phrases or flowery terminology. (1990, pp. 66-67)
This type of description is less concerned with the factual accuracy and more focused on the person's living sense of the experience. What is it like to live through an experience?
Written descriptions of student experiences in WCC were taken at two points in the two years they used conferencing in their program and were a part of the text used for the study. In addition to written descriptions of the experience, conversations provided a valuable source to understand the lived-experience.
Conversation is a process of coming into an understanding. Thus it belongs to every true conversation that each person opens himself to the other, truly accepts his point of view as valid and transposes himself into the other to such an extent that he understands not the particular individual but what he says. (Gadamer, 1994/ 1960, p. 385)
Gadamer suggests that we fall into conversations. We are led by the conversation. To have a conversation means
to allow oneself to be conducted by the subject matter to which the partners in the dialogue are oriented. It requires that one does not try to argue the other person down but that one really considers the weight of the other's opinion. Hence the art of testing. But the art of testing is the art of questioning [and] to question means to lay open to place in the open. (Gadamer, 1994/1960, p. 367)
It is through this process of laying open that I understand your experience. It is a pathway to finding common meaning. For van Manen (1990), conversations provide an avenue to collect personal stories rooted in specific instances and events as well as an opportunity to form a relationship with the other about the meaning of an experience.
I had two face-to-face conversations with each student participating in my dissertation research. The students experienced WCC as a component of their program over a two-year period. Seven students participated in the study. Each conversation lasted between one to two hours. Each conversation was audio taped and a transcript was produced from the tape. I reviewed the initial round of conversations for themes and clues for places I wanted to probe more deeply. I also conducted a virtual focus group that met in a real-time chat space to discuss and clarify aspects of the experience of being in a WCC. From the transcript of the chat session and the individual transcripts, I arranged to have another set of individual face-to-face conversations with the student participants. The second set of conversations lasted about one to two hours. The conversations were audio recorded and transcripts were produced from the tapes.
The conversations had both a face-to-face component and a virtual component. The texts generated from both provided the basic source material for my interpretation. Several other texts also provide insight into the experience of WCC. Experiential descriptions in literature, biography, and art are all sources for lived experience (van Manen, 1990). Phenomenological literature offers insights into lived-experience, but is different from other literature. According to van Manen, phenomenological literature is different in four ways:
(1) Phenomenological literature may contain material which has already addressed in a descriptive or an interpretive manner the very topic or question which occupies us.
(2) The work of other phenomenologists turns into a source for us with which to dialogue.
(3) Selected phenomenological materials enable us to reflect more deeply on the way we tend to make interpretive sense of lived experience.
(4) Phenomenological sources allow us to see our limits and to transcend the limits of our interpretive sensibilities. (van Manen, 1990, pp. 74-76)
(2) The work of other phenomenologists turns into a source for us with which to dialogue.
(3) Selected phenomenological materials enable us to reflect more deeply on the way we tend to make interpretive sense of lived experience.
(4) Phenomenological sources allow us to see our limits and to transcend the limits of our interpretive sensibilities. (van Manen, 1990, pp. 74-76)
Once I had gathered textual sources, the next step was to begin the process of interpretation and the process of identifying meaning units.
Characterizing the Phenomenon Using Themes
What is the process through which I take the text I have carefully brought together into meaning units or themes? How do I identify the nature of the lived experience as it is reflected in the text collected in my study?
To do human science research is to be involved in the crafting of a text. In order to come to grips with the structure of meaning of the text… in terms of meaning units, structures of meaning or themes. Reflecting on lived experience then becomes reflectively analyzing the structural or thematic aspects of that experience. (van Manen, 1990, p. 78)
Theme comes from the Latin word thema, what is laid down. Thema is a thesis (Webster's, 1979, p. 1891). A thesis is "a position, from tihenai, to put, place." A theme is placed, laid down. It is tied to a position, a value, meaning. "Phenomenological themes may be understood as the structures of experience" (van Manen, 1990, p. 79). For van Manen, a theme "is the experience of focus, of meaning, of point; …formulation is at best a simplification; …is not an object one encounters at certain points or moments in the text [a theme is not a thing]; …is the form of capturing the phenomenon one tries to understand" (p. 87).
Van Manen suggests three processes for isolating thematic statements: "the wholistic or sententious approach; the selective or highlighting approach; and the detailed or line-by line approach" (1990, p. 93). Each approach guides a different view of the text differing in how specific the lens of examination. The first approach is more global, seeking overall meaning of the text. The second approach focuses on phrases or sentences that stand out in the text. The third approach is a close examination of the text sentence by sentence.
Through the use of hermeneutic conversation, "keeping the question (of the meaning of phenomenon) open, to keep [myself] and the interviewee oriented to the substance of the thing questioned" (van Manen, 1990, p. 98), the meaning of the experience of students in WCC was examined. Students were encouraged to reflect on their experiences to determine the deeper meanings and themes of their experiences. Once the transcripts were generated from the conversations, the students and I reflected on the conversations for meaning both in focus group and an additional conversation.
All phenomenological research involves "explorations into the structure of the human lifeworld, the lived world as experienced in everyday situations and relations" (van Manen, 1990, p. 101). Van Manen suggests there are four fundamental lifeworld themes that are helpful guides for reflection: "lived space (spatiality), lived body (corporeality), lived time (temporality), and lived human relation (relationality or communality)" (p. 101). While these four themes can be identified they can not be separated in the lived world of experience. In my initial exploration of WCC, all of these themes are evident. The challenge was to connect these fundamental themes to the experiences growing out of the web-based environment in a fresh and "lived" way.
Perhaps the most difficult part the thematizing process is determining the difference between universal or essential qualities of a theme and those that are more incidentally related to the phenomenon. "In determining the universal or essential quality of a theme our concern is to discover aspects or qualities that make a phenomenon what it is and without which the phenomenon could not be what it is" (van Manen, 1990, p. 107).
The structuring of meaning with themes sets the stage for the process of "bringing speech to something" (van Manen, 1990, p. 32), the art of writing and rewriting.
The Art of Writing and Rewriting
"Human science research is a form of writing. Creating a phenomenological text is the object of the research process" (van Manen, 1990, p. 111).
All writing is a kind of alienated speech, and its signs need to be transformed back into speech and meaning. Because the meaning has undergone self-alienation through being written down, this transformation back is the real hermeneutical task. The meaning of what has been said is to be started anew, simply on the basis of the words passed on by means of the written signs. (Gadamer, 1994/1960, p. 393)
"Writing separates us from what we know and yet it unites us more closely with what I know" (van Manen, 1990, p. 127). I began to know myself by externalizing an internal sense that is immersed within the situation I am unable to see beyond the moment of this internal sea in the writing. Writing facilitates this movement from internal to external. "We come to know what we know in this dialectical process of constructing text (a body of knowledge) and thus learning what we are capable of saying (our knowing body)" (p. 127).
Writing also separates us from lived experience and through this separation I am able to reflect on everyday experience. It is through writing that the lived experience of WCC allowed me to examine its essence. Immersed in the experience, the experience is seamless without reflection. To step back in reflection, the edges begin to be clear, and slowly I began to see what has been nothing more than a sequence of activities. Is this similar to Heidegger's (1996/1952) seamless use of the hammer? How does writing as a reflection compare to the reflection that occurs when equipment is dysfunctional in some manner?
Writing decontextualizes thought from practice and yet it returns thought to praxis…. [It] focuses our reflective awareness by disregarding the incidentals and contingencies that constitute the social, physical, and biographic context of a particular situation. But as we gain in this manner a deeper sense of meanings embedded in some isolated aspect of practice we are also being prepared to become more discerning of the meaning of new life experiences. (van Manen, 1990, p. 128)
My experience of the world becomes abstract as I describe it in writing. It is intellectualized. Yet through my description?my story of an experience, it is possible to draw you into the feeling of the experience by making it concrete. "The narrative power of story is that sometimes it can be more compelling, more moving, more physically and emotionally stirring than the lived-life itself" (van Manen, 1990, p. 129).
"Writing objectifies thought into print and yet it subjectifies our understanding of something that truly engages us" (van Manen, 1990, p. 129). For van Manen, "research is writing in that it places consciousness in the position of the possibility of confronting itself, in a self-reflective relation" (p. 129). In phenomenological text, "it lets us see that which shines through, that which tends to hide itself…. To read or write phenomenologically requires that we be sensitively attentive to the silence around the words by means of which we attempt to disclose the deep meaning of the world" (p. 131).
Maintaining a Strong and Oriented Relation
Van Manen suggests that modern educational theory and research suffers from three main problems: "(1) confusing pedagogical theories with other discipline-based forms of discourse; (2) tending to abstraction and thus losing touch with the lifeworld of the living; and (3) failing to see the general erosion of pedagogic meaning from the lifeworld" (1990, p. 135). The focus of the writing and the research needs to be guided continually and demonstrate from where we stand pedagogically. The focus on pedagogy in the phenomenological text grounds the research in a perspective that can inform educational practice. "Learning to understand the essence of pedagogy as it manifests itself in particular life circumstances contributes to a more hermeneutic type of competence: a pedagogic thoughtfulness and tact" (van Manen, p. 143).
Pedagogy in the sense van Manen (1990) is using it goes beyond a positivist model that depends on certain observable behaviors or actions. It resides in what we experience and know as intrinsic in the human experience of teaching. Pedagogical theory "has to be the theory of the unique, of particular case" (p. 150). In this sense, pedagogy in WCC is rooted in our experience of teaching. While WCC is unique, it is intimately linked to teaching.
Van Manen (1990) suggests that the research/writing and also evaluative criteria of any phenomenological human science text need to be oriented, strong, rich, and deep. An oriented text is one that is "understood as an answer to the question of how an educator stands in life, how an educator needs to think about [students], how an educator observes, listens, and relates to [students], how an educator practices a form of speaking and writing that is pedagogically contagious" (p. 151). A strong text "always needs to aim for the strongest pedagogic interpretation of a certain phenomenon" (p. 151). For a text to be rich, "the meanings of the lived sense of the phenomenon are not exhausted in their immediate experience. A rich and thick description is concrete, exploring a phenomenon in all its experiential ramifications" (p. 152). A text with rich descriptions, that explores meaning structures beyond what is immediately experienced, gains a dimension of depth. Merleau-Ponty expresses it this way: "Depth is the means the things have to remain things, while not being what I look at at present" (cited in van Manen, 1990, p. 152). How will these evaluative criteria transfer to a multimedia/hypermedia text?
Van Manen (1990) believes that human science is a critically oriented action research?a philosophy of action in three ways. "Hermeneutic phenomenological reflection deepens thought and therefore radicalizes thinking and the acting that flows from it" (p. 154). The critical action flows from a deeper understanding of the lived experience. Second, "phenomenology is a philosophy of actions especially in a pedagogic context. Pedagogy itself is a mode of life that always and by definition deals with practical action" (p. 154). A focus on pedagogy in educational research leads naturally to action. The research I have done thus far has informed my pedagogic practices in WCC. It is from an informed place that I can show others. Finally, "phenomenology is a philosophy of action always in a personal and situated sense. A person who turns to phenomenological reflection does so out of personal engagement" (p. 154). I am studying student experiences of WCC not only from a deep personal questioning coming from inside myself, but also from students who experienced WCC as part of their program in the Institute for Educational Transformation (IET).
Balancing the Research Context
The research plan or proposal is a balance of explicit statements on the methodological process and an openness that "allows for choosing directions and exploring techniques, procedures and sources that are not always foreseeable at the outset of a research project" (van Manen, 1990, p. 162). In terms of ethics, van Manen believes that the researcher needs to be aware of the following:
(1) The research may have certain effects on the people with whom the research is concerned and who will be interested in the phenomenological work.
(2) There are possible effects of the research methods on the institutions in which the research is conducted.
(3) The research methods used may have lingering effects on the actual "subjects" involved in the study.
(4) Phenomenological projects and their methods often have a transformative effect on the researcher. (pp. 162-153)
(2) There are possible effects of the research methods on the institutions in which the research is conducted.
(3) The research methods used may have lingering effects on the actual "subjects" involved in the study.
(4) Phenomenological projects and their methods often have a transformative effect on the researcher. (pp. 162-153)
Van Manen (1990) suggests that there are several ways to structure phenomenological research: thematically, analytically, exemplificatively, exergetically, existentially, and inventing an approach (pp. 168-173). While my initial exploration into the phenomenon was thematic, my method for approaching the writing is of my own invention.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)